Connecting University Circle
Brought to You by PNC

Share This

Close

« back to news list

Rethink existing transportation systems with Transportation Demand Managemen

Posted August 17, 2017 in Articles

Author: Paul Mackie

Jeffrey Tumlin is a leading thinker – a mover-and-shaker – on incorporating “transportation demand management” principles into the many ways planners are rethinking the ways we’ve built our cities.

I didn’t attend the Association for Commuter Transportation’s recent annual conference in New Orleans, but several of our readers told me how his keynote speech was inspiring that I had some followup questions. Here are his answers, which I think are very compelling ideas for business and city leaders and planners to easily grab onto and should show TDM experts how they can proceed with exciting ideas to apply to their own communities.

(Tumlin is principal and director of strategy at planning consultant Nelson/Nygaard. One of his most-recent projects was to help Oakland start a department of transportation. He said one of his guiding philosophies was that a DOT is not about building more roads because that only “works for about five minutes, until people ask ‘why not move to the bigger house five minutes farther away?’ He said the way to run a DOT is to collect and use really smart data to see how re-engineering solutions can happen within existing infrastructure. Sounds a lot like TDM, right?)

Mobility Lab: When cities have nowhere to expand and they’re out of space to build big infrastructure projects, how do you see TDM as the best and most cost-effective option?

Jeffrey Tumlin: Infrastructure is supply-side economics. TDM is demand-side. Too much emphasis on either side causes problems. Successful cities and companies provide a careful balance between the two, knowing that TDM’s job is to help us make the most efficient use of our capital investments. For cities that want to grow – and don’t want to rip out neighborhoods for new highways – TDM is an essential tool for moving more people in the same amount of road space.

Fixed transit has so many problems and needs to up its game. How should TDM get into that game?

Thriving high-capacity transit is essential for the economic future of cities, and becomes even more so as autonomous vehicles enter the market. But in their current form, conventional public transit agencies are a failed business model. They have no control over their operating environment (streets), they are not allowed to capture the value they create, and they rarely measure what they’re best at.

As technology and demographics change, public transit agencies make sense only in partnership with cities and developers. This doesn’t necessary mean organizational restructuring, but it does require an attitude shift by all the players. TDM can help transit by making it more efficient and relevant. Columbus, Ohio recently realized that it’s cheaper to give all downtown employees free bus passes than it is to build parking for those employees. But such a deal only works if cities, businesses, and transit collaborate, and only if they think like TDM people think.

How should TDM and transit get into the AV game?

AVs are going to require a more radical attitude shift by transit agencies if they hope to survive. Once Uber and Lyft eliminate their drivers, they’ll cost about the same per mile as driving yourself, and most urban trips will cost about the same as bus fare. Why on earth would anyone wait for the bus if a driverless Uber offers door-to-door convenience and far higher quality? While congestion-protected buses in Seattle are thriving, like urban rail in most regions, Uber and Lyft are already creating a drop-off in bus ridership where transit is stuck in congestion.

Some agencies are adapting by eliminating poorly performing routes and replacing that coverage with subsidized TNCs [transportation network companies, like Uber and Lyft]. But a dirty secret in the transit industry is the cost of retiree healthcare and pensions, which is paid in part by contributions from the current workforce. Lose too many of today’s workers, and those retirement packages go bankrupt. How many public transit agencies will enter the service-cut death spiral before most riders flee? And what happens to city street and highway congestion when every 80-passenger urban bus is replaced by 20 to 80 driverless Ubers?

Most transit agencies will ignore the problem until it is too late, like the taxi industry did [with TNCs]. A few savvy ones will recognize that their survival requires new leadership and partnerships, and they’ll be spurred on by cities, who know that an unregulated AV future is a disaster for their economies. This means recognizing that the best urban market for AVs is bus rapid transit (BRT), because we already have the computing power to allow high-capacity AV buses to operate safely in dedicated rights of way. It means seeing that AV BRT can operate every two minutes, 24 hours a day, at nearly no marginal cost, and move 10 times as many people per lane as a fleet of Google pods.

It also means understanding that the job category “bus driver” will not exist 20 years from now – any more than “elevator operator” does today. Transit agencies and labor may prefer to avoid this reality, but avoidance today means a lot of people will lose their livelihoods and pensions some years from now. The technological shift will happen slowly enough that thoughtful leadership now can ensure no one is thrown into poverty, and that transit takes on a new primary role of delivering real capacity in dense urban corridors.

TDM planners can help cities and transit agencies avoid the nightmare scenario by doing what we do best: Bringing people together, explaining how different scenarios play out, and asking what capital investments and management techniques result in the best outcomes.

You mentioned something along the lines that people who ride bikes aren’t better than other people, they are just using up less geometric space. Why does that seem like a difficult concept to grasp for people who don’t ride bikes (and maybe some who do)?

The whole simplistic bikes versus cars war seems to arise from three key sources:

First, there is our tendency toward “object” thinking versus “systems” thinking. If I’m in a car, and there is a slow cyclist in front of me, I could wish that she would go “away” and not delay me, ignoring the fact that if she weren’t on a bike she’d likely be in a car and cause me even more delay. Transport is a complex system, and the secondary impacts of transport investments can be even greater than the primary impacts.

Second is self-involvement. In the case of Columbus, or downtown Boulder, it was clear that it was cheaper to offer free transit passes to all downtown employees than it was to build additional parking for those who drive. So even if I want to drive every day, it’s cheaper for me to pay other people not to drive than it is for you to build me a parking space.

Third is what is awkwardly called “othering.” The events in Charlottesville this week offer an extreme picture of how we can define people by identity categories and thereby reject our common humanity. Saying “we shouldn’t build bike lanes because cyclists never stop at stop signs” is far less extreme than “immigrants are thugs,” but these statements are rooted in a belief that some people – “cyclists,” “immigrants,” “African-Americans” – are a different brand of human. Not like me. Not deserving of full participation in the social contract. I am not a “cyclist,” but I am someone who sometimes rides a bike when I’m not in a car or bus or on foot.

Anything else to add?

As TDM professionals, our task is to focus on people, and their choices, not infrastructure. So we have to understand human psychology, desires, and fears. We offer a path out of these destructive, dehumanizing debates.

Original Article: https://mobilitylab.org/2017/08/17/redesign-rethink-u-s-s-existing-transportation-tumlin/?utm_source=%2523117+-+September+1%252C+2017&utm_campaign=%2523117&utm_medium=email

TOMORROW! Join us for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 27 to hear updates on pedestrian saf...

TOMORROW! Join us for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 27 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

TOMORROW! Join us for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 27 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Tuesday, March 26 2024 | 10:01am

🚨 Traffic Alert: Upcoming scheduled crane work at the Cleveland VA Medical Center will result in temporary closures of E. 105th Stre...

🚨 Traffic Alert: Upcoming scheduled crane work at the Cleveland VA Medical Center will result in temporary closures of E. 105th Street northbound lanes between Martin Luther King Jr. Drive and Magnolia Drive. Southbound travel lanes will remain open at all times. The lane closures are scheduled...

🚨 Traffic Alert: Upcoming scheduled crane work at the Cleveland VA Medical Center will result in temporary closures of E. 105th Street northbound lanes between Martin Luther King Jr. Drive and Magnolia Drive. Southbound travel lanes will remain open at all times. The lane closures are scheduled to occur as follows, subject to weather: • Monday, March 25 and Tuesday, March 26 - 7:00am – 4:00pm • Monday, April 1 - 7:00am – 4:00pm • Friday, April 5 - 7:00am – 4:00pm

Friday, March 22 2024 | 12:38pm

Join us for an insightful webinar hosted by uGO where we will explore the range of commuter benefits offered by NOACA and GCRTA. Whethe...

Join us for an insightful webinar hosted by uGO where we will explore the range of commuter benefits offered by NOACA and GCRTA. Whether you're an individual looking to save money on your daily travels or an employer seeking to enhance your benefits package, this webinar is for you. During this ses...

Join us for an insightful webinar hosted by uGO where we will explore the range of commuter benefits offered by NOACA and GCRTA. Whether you're an individual looking to save money on your daily travels or an employer seeking to enhance your benefits package, this webinar is for you. During this session, we'll dive into the commuter benefits offered by these organizations such as pre-tax transit cost savings, subsidized vanpools, and guaranteed rides home. Learn how these benefits can not only lighten the financial burden of commuting but also reduce carbon emissions and ease traffic congestion. Register to attend here: bit.ly/uGOwebinar24

Friday, March 15 2024 | 1:00pm

Join us TOMORROW for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safet...

Join us TOMORROW for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Join us TOMORROW for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Tuesday, March 12 2024 | 11:00am

Did you know RTA has free parking at nine stations along the Red Line? It can be an excellent Park-n-Ride option for those who don’t ...

Did you know RTA has free parking at nine stations along the Red Line? It can be an excellent Park-n-Ride option for those who don’t live close to a train or bus stop!

Did you know RTA has free parking at nine stations along the Red Line? It can be an excellent Park-n-Ride option for those who don’t live close to a train or bus stop!

Monday, March 11 2024 | 12:00pm

Are you tired of walking the same loop on your lunch break? Looking to switch up your routine? Check out uGO's downloadable maps that s...

Are you tired of walking the same loop on your lunch break? Looking to switch up your routine? Check out uGO's downloadable maps that show recommended routes for walking in University Circle. Visit uGOinthecircle.com/walking for more walking loops.

Are you tired of walking the same loop on your lunch break? Looking to switch up your routine? Check out uGO's downloadable maps that show recommended routes for walking in University Circle. Visit uGOinthecircle.com/walking for more walking loops.

Friday, March 8 2024 | 9:00am

Join UCI and UCPD next week for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedes...

Join UCI and UCPD next week for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Join UCI and UCPD next week for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Wednesday, March 6 2024 | 11:00am

The City of Cleveland is hosting a community meeting this Thursday at 5:00 pm to share information about the upcoming resurfacing of Ca...

The City of Cleveland is hosting a community meeting this Thursday at 5:00 pm to share information about the upcoming resurfacing of Carnegie Avenue between E. 79th Street and MLK Jr. Drive. Final Design is scheduled to be completed in June 2024. Construction is scheduled to begin March 2025.

The City of Cleveland is hosting a community meeting this Thursday at 5:00 pm to share information about the upcoming resurfacing of Carnegie Avenue between E. 79th Street and MLK Jr. Drive. Final Design is scheduled to be completed in June 2024. Construction is scheduled to begin March 2025.

Monday, March 4 2024 | 10:48am

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safe...

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Wednesday, February 28 2024 | 11:25am

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safe...

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom on Wednesday, March 13 to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Wednesday, February 21 2024 | 7:00am

University Circle is conveniently served by six bus routes, the Euclid Avenue HealthLine (bus rapid transit), and the Red Line (heavy r...

University Circle is conveniently served by six bus routes, the Euclid Avenue HealthLine (bus rapid transit), and the Red Line (heavy rail). Use GCRTA's System Map or the Transit App on your phone to learn more about these transit routes and where they lead: riderta.com/systemmap.

University Circle is conveniently served by six bus routes, the Euclid Avenue HealthLine (bus rapid transit), and the Red Line (heavy rail). Use GCRTA's System Map or the Transit App on your phone to learn more about these transit routes and where they lead: riderta.com/systemmap.

Friday, February 16 2024 | 9:00am

The CircleLink shuttle connects University Circle to its outside neighborhoods making it the perfect way to travel locally. Get real-ti...

The CircleLink shuttle connects University Circle to its outside neighborhoods making it the perfect way to travel locally. Get real-time updates on the location of shuttles in the Circle and more on our shuttle page: ugointhecircle.com/shuttle

The CircleLink shuttle connects University Circle to its outside neighborhoods making it the perfect way to travel locally. Get real-time updates on the location of shuttles in the Circle and more on our shuttle page: ugointhecircle.com/shuttle

Monday, February 12 2024 | 9:01am

FYI! Lot 54, the parking lot at the former Ford Road Garage site, is now open and available for public parking. The 75-space parking lo...

FYI! Lot 54, the parking lot at the former Ford Road Garage site, is now open and available for public parking. The 75-space parking lot is owned and operated by Case Western Reserve University with visitor parking available at a rate of $1/hour.

FYI! Lot 54, the parking lot at the former Ford Road Garage site, is now open and available for public parking. The 75-space parking lot is owned and operated by Case Western Reserve University with visitor parking available at a rate of $1/hour.

Wednesday, February 7 2024 | 7:00am

With incoming snow expected to exceed 2 inches, please remember that stopping, standing, and parking of vehicles will be restricted and...

With incoming snow expected to exceed 2 inches, please remember that stopping, standing, and parking of vehicles will be restricted and prohibited on City streets with the posted red and white signs. In University Circle, this applies to the following roadways: Cedar Avenue, Chester Avenue, Euclid A...

With incoming snow expected to exceed 2 inches, please remember that stopping, standing, and parking of vehicles will be restricted and prohibited on City streets with the posted red and white signs. In University Circle, this applies to the following roadways: Cedar Avenue, Chester Avenue, Euclid Avenue, Martin Luther King Jr. Drive, and Wade Park Avenue.

Thursday, January 18 2024 | 6:00pm

Explore University Circle on foot this winter using one of our walking tours! Take a walk and grab lunch in Uptown, visit the museums o...

Explore University Circle on foot this winter using one of our walking tours! Take a walk and grab lunch in Uptown, visit the museums on Wade Oval, or take in the beautiful scenery of Wade Park.

Explore University Circle on foot this winter using one of our walking tours! Take a walk and grab lunch in Uptown, visit the museums on Wade Oval, or take in the beautiful scenery of Wade Park.

Wednesday, January 17 2024 | 3:02pm

This is a reminder that University Circle shuttles are operating on a winter break schedule. For more details, view the table below or ...

This is a reminder that University Circle shuttles are operating on a winter break schedule. For more details, view the table below or visit our shuttle page: ugointhecircle.com/shuttle.

This is a reminder that University Circle shuttles are operating on a winter break schedule. For more details, view the table below or visit our shuttle page: ugointhecircle.com/shuttle.

Monday, January 8 2024 | 9:01am

Happy New Year from uGO! Let’s talk about transportation and New Year’s Resolutions. What's the most common New Year's Resolution?...

Happy New Year from uGO! Let’s talk about transportation and New Year’s Resolutions. What's the most common New Year's Resolution? You guessed it - to exercise more and lose weight. Purchasing a new gym membership and establishing a workout routine are common next steps to accomplish this goal,...

Happy New Year from uGO! Let’s talk about transportation and New Year’s Resolutions. What's the most common New Year's Resolution? You guessed it - to exercise more and lose weight. Purchasing a new gym membership and establishing a workout routine are common next steps to accomplish this goal, but what if we told you that your commute can also play a role? Studies have shown that people who use transit take 30% more steps per day on average than people who drive, and nearly a third of transit users are physically active for 30 minutes or more each day just from walking to and from their pickup location. Similarly, studies show that the average person loses 13 lbs. in the first year of commuting by bike! Interested in changing up your commute for 2024? Check out our Transit and Biking pages on uGOinthecircle.com for information to help you get started!

Monday, January 1 2024 | 9:01am

Don't forget that University Circle shuttles do not operate on New Year's Day. RTA buses and trains operate on the holiday schedule. Vi...

Don't forget that University Circle shuttles do not operate on New Year's Day. RTA buses and trains operate on the holiday schedule. Visit our shuttle page for more info: uGOinthecircle.com/shuttle

Don't forget that University Circle shuttles do not operate on New Year's Day. RTA buses and trains operate on the holiday schedule. Visit our shuttle page for more info: uGOinthecircle.com/shuttle

Friday, December 29 2023 | 9:00am

A friendly reminder that University Circle shuttles do not operate on Christmas Day. RTA buses and trains operate on the holiday schedu...

A friendly reminder that University Circle shuttles do not operate on Christmas Day. RTA buses and trains operate on the holiday schedule. Visit our shuttle page for more info: uGOinthecircle.com/shuttle

A friendly reminder that University Circle shuttles do not operate on Christmas Day. RTA buses and trains operate on the holiday schedule. Visit our shuttle page for more info: uGOinthecircle.com/shuttle

Friday, December 22 2023 | 9:01am

Explore University Circle on foot using one of our walking tours! Take a walk and grab lunch in Uptown, visit the Museums on Wade Oval,...

Explore University Circle on foot using one of our walking tours! Take a walk and grab lunch in Uptown, visit the Museums on Wade Oval, or take in the beautiful scenery of Wade Park.

Explore University Circle on foot using one of our walking tours! Take a walk and grab lunch in Uptown, visit the Museums on Wade Oval, or take in the beautiful scenery of Wade Park.

Thursday, December 14 2023 | 1:00pm

In coordination with Case Western Reserve University’s winter break schedule, a few shuttle routes will temporarily change starting t...

In coordination with Case Western Reserve University’s winter break schedule, a few shuttle routes will temporarily change starting this weekend. View the table and stay up to date with the latest changes on our shuttle page: ugointhecircle.com/shuttle

In coordination with Case Western Reserve University’s winter break schedule, a few shuttle routes will temporarily change starting this weekend. View the table and stay up to date with the latest changes on our shuttle page: ugointhecircle.com/shuttle

Wednesday, December 13 2023 | 4:27pm

Join UCI and UCPD tomorrow evening for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom to hear updates on pedestrian safety in ...

Join UCI and UCPD tomorrow evening for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Join UCI and UCPD tomorrow evening for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Tuesday, December 5 2023 | 9:01am

Pedestrian friendly bumper stickers make great stocking stuffers! Request one for all the pedestrian friendly drivers on your list this...

Pedestrian friendly bumper stickers make great stocking stuffers! Request one for all the pedestrian friendly drivers on your list this year: universitycircle.org/project-yield-sticker

Pedestrian friendly bumper stickers make great stocking stuffers! Request one for all the pedestrian friendly drivers on your list this year: universitycircle.org/project-yield-sticker

Monday, December 4 2023 | 9:01am

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle...

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Join UCI and UCPD for a Pedestrian Safety Advisory Community meeting via Zoom to hear updates on pedestrian safety in University Circle and share your road safety concerns. Learn more and register here: universitycircle.org/project-yield

Wednesday, November 29 2023 | 9:00am

Happy (almost) Thanksgiving! This is a reminder that University Circle shuttles will not be running on Thanksgiving Day. To find altern...

Happy (almost) Thanksgiving! This is a reminder that University Circle shuttles will not be running on Thanksgiving Day. To find alternative modes of transportation, follow the link! ugointhecircle.com/plan-your-trip

Happy (almost) Thanksgiving! This is a reminder that University Circle shuttles will not be running on Thanksgiving Day. To find alternative modes of transportation, follow the link! ugointhecircle.com/plan-your-trip

Tuesday, November 21 2023 | 10:01am

Stay Connected

Sign up to receive alerts and/or uGO's seldom email communications.

Calculate Your Commute

How much are you spending on your way to work?

Show Me

Stay Connected! Sign up to receive transportation alerts and stay up to date on uGO news.

Photo Gallery

1 of 22